Changes proposed for process of selecting Iowa district court judges
DES MOINES — Republicans in the Iowa Senate are considering changes in the process for nominating district court judges after Governor Kim Reynolds accused a judge from Humboldt of unprofessional behavior as he led a local nominating commission.
Reynolds rejected a slate of candidates for a district court judgeship in November after fielding complaints that the judge leading the nominating commission coached one candidate and made negative comments about another.
A Senate bill would remove the chief district court judge from local nominating commissions and let the governor appoint a majority of the commissioners. Republican Senator Julian Garrett of Indianola said while the incident this fall was extreme, he’s heard similar concerns in other Iowa districts, “along the lines of attorneys really reluctant to say anything contradictory to the judge.”
The Iowa Judicial Branch and the Iowa Supreme Court are opposed to the bill.
“We believe it is best to have judges involved in the process of selecting judges,” said Caitlin Jarzen, the state court administrator. “We understand that there has been an issue with this process at the district level. However, that issue was addressed and resolved and we don’t believe that the entire system needs to be changed because of it.”
Other opponents say the proposed change would inject more politics in the judicial selection process. The proposed change for the commissions that nominate district court judges mirrors a law passed a few years ago for the nominating commission that picks finalists for the Iowa Supreme Court and Court of Appeals. The governor then appoints a justice from the list of nominees.