FBI and NYPD Raid Former Chief Jeffrey Maddrey’s Home Amid Sexual Misconduct Allegations
NEW YORK — Federal agents and NYPD’s Internal Affairs Bureau raided the Queens home of former NYPD Chief of Department Jeffrey Maddrey on Thursday, marking a significant escalation in the investigation into allegations that Maddrey exchanged sexual favors for overtime pay.
Search warrants were executed at Maddrey’s residence on 147th Road in Rosedale, as well as at other undisclosed locations.
Investigators were seen removing boxes and documents from his home. The raid coincided with Maddrey’s official suspension, as announced by NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch.
The investigation stems from allegations made by NYPD Lieutenant Quathisha Epps, who accused Maddrey of sexual harassment and coercion.
Epps claims Maddrey demanded sexual favors in exchange for granting her overtime opportunities and retaliated against her when she refused.
“Under my direction, the Internal Affairs Bureau is collaborating with law enforcement to thoroughly investigate these allegations,” Tisch stated. “Maddrey was suspended this morning as search warrants were executed.”
Resignation and Fallout
Maddrey, 53, abruptly resigned and filed for retirement on December 20 following the allegations. Though he remains technically on the NYPD’s payroll for 30 days after retiring, the suspension could impact his post-retirement benefits.
If terminated before his retirement becomes official, Maddrey would retain his pension but lose the NYPD retiree ID card and “good guy letter,” which certifies good standing for future employment.
City Hall spokeswoman Kayla Mamelak declined to comment on whether Mayor Eric Adams, a longtime ally of Maddrey who promoted him to Chief of Department, was informed of the raid beforehand. “The mayor is working closely with Commissioner Tisch as this investigation unfolds,” Mamelak stated.
Epps’ Allegations and Broader Implications
Epps, named the NYPD’s highest-paid employee in 2024 with earnings of $406,515, filed a complaint with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. She alleges Maddrey added her to an internal list of top overtime earners as retaliation after she rejected his advances.
Commissioner Tisch has since initiated a department-wide review of overtime practices. Additionally, she has overhauled the Internal Affairs Bureau, replacing key leadership, including those responsible for investigating claims against Maddrey. Deputy Chief Paul Saraceno, who served as Maddrey’s second-in-command, was reassigned earlier this week.
Legal and Investigative Developments
Maddrey’s attorney, Peter Brill, maintains his client’s innocence. “We are prepared to answer any questions the federal investigators may have,” Brill stated. Meanwhile, Epps’ attorney, Eric Sanders, declined to confirm whether federal authorities have interviewed his client.
The Southern District of New York, leading the federal investigation, declined to comment on the raids or the criminal inquiry.
Amid the fallout, John Chell was sworn in as the new NYPD Chief of Department on New Year’s Eve, signaling a fresh start for the department as it confronts the scandal.
The case highlights significant issues within the NYPD regarding workplace misconduct and overtime management, with the investigation ongoing and potential charges yet to be filed.
